← Main Menu  |  Book Contents  |  ← Chapter 6  |  Chapter 7  |  Chapter 8 →

The Rise and Fall of The NEW Four Seasons 1966 to 1977

Chapter 7 — The Plans for a NEW Four Seasons

As 1977 started, The Four Seasons seemed to be well positioned as they were the top 1976 sellers for Warner Bros (George Benson was 2nd). So the group and management must have been confident about the future.

Chapter image 1

Record World certainly thought so and ( on Jan 8th 1977) issued a Music Industry 22 page promo 'Tribute to Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons' and celebrated their 15th year in the industry. Warner's execs, agencies, promo firms and even Bob Crewe all contributed congratulatory messages/articles and the magazine featured bios and interviews with all the members and Bob Gaudio. And Frankie Valli had the major success of his ‘Close-Up’ album on Private Stock PVLP 1001 in 1975.

The combined success of ‘My Eyes Adored You’ and ‘ Swearin’ To God’ [the extended version PVT-12 DJ 12 inch MIX only found here…..and on the album] had refired Frankie Valli’s solo career thanks to the production skill of Bob Crewe. However the recurring fall-outs between Gaudio-Valli and Crewe were resurfacing with his addiction problems but as always they needed Bob Crewe [as will be seen again later in the book] to find a ‘sound’ that was ‘commercial’.

In 1974 and 1975, Bob Crewe had pioneered the NYC gay club scene primarily by conceptualizing, writing, and producing the music of Disco Tex and the Sex-O-Lettes. He co-wrote and produced their massive hit ‘Get Dancin', which peaked at No. 10 on the Billboard Hot 100 in early 1975. He followed it with "I Wanna Dance Wit' Choo (Doo Dat Dance)" later that year. This project intentionally brought unadulterated gay club culture, camp, and drag aesthetics out of the underground and into mainstream pop. In addition The Labelle version of "Lady Marmalade" (co-written by Bob Crewe and Kenny Nolan, and famously produced by Allen Toussaint alongside Vicki Wickham) reached number one on the US Billboard Hot 100 chart on March 29, 1975, staying at the top spot for a single week. Bob’s focus then switched to the 1976 album ‘Street Talk’ by The Bob Crewe Generation which he planned as a Broadway-bound disco-rock ballet depicting Hollywood life, produced and intentionally crafted as a highly queer, homoerotic disco concept piece. Crewe, who was openly bisexual in an era when most music executives remained closeted, used this instrumental-heavy Elektra Records release to lean heavily into the hedonistic, liberated energy of the mid-1970s gay club subculture. It was released on 30th August 1976

Whilst Bob Gaudio and Frankie were riding high on the success of the ‘Who Loves You’ album in 1977 the year also started with a near fatal tragedy as newspapers reported:

” News from LA….Bob Crewe is victim of a hit and run accident and is nearly killed. He was taken to UCLA Hospital and after intensive care (his leg was reported to have 20 breaks) he has now been taken off the critical list. His recovery is expected to be 12 weeks.”

In fact he spent months in a body cast before rehab and eventually got back into the Memphis studio to record a solo album 'Motivation' with legendary producer Jerry Wexler with release in May 1977 (featuring The Bob Crewe Generation). Unlike his usual instrumental or production projects, this ‘recovery’ album uniquely served as a showcase for Crewe's own lead singing voice.

It perhaps wasn’t a time for public comment on the past relationship between the two ‘legendary’ song writer/producers and their primary star artist but the media dug down in interviews. During the recording of the 'Close-Up' album in late 1974 and early 1975 the on-off relationship between Crewe and Gaudio had once again cooled and divisions which had dogged their relationship through the 60s re-surfaced. The production of tracks for the album had been split between them with Charlie Calello as arranger being the 'glue' holding it together. Crewe produced 4 tracks at Media Studios New York and Gaudio 4 tracks at the Sound Factory Hollywood. Amazingly the album held together as a classic. An article that appeared in Crawdaddy magazine in February 1977 however showed how deep the rift was……

“There has long been an often heated controversy both inside and outside the Four Seasons organisation, concerning who deserves the majority of credit for the “genius”, as Frankie Valli puts it, behind the group's sound. Apart from the glaring presence of Valli's technically amazing voice, some say their considerable commercial success should be attributed in the main to the compositional flair of Bob Gaudio. Others feel the kudos should go to Bob Crewe, who was cranking out hits with Frank Slay and other collaborators before, during and after the Seasons halcyon days. The matter isn't close to being settled, having recently contributed to a rift between Crewe and Valli. (The other reason, according to Valli is that Crewe stuck him with “$30,000 to $40,000 worth of unfinished tracks” for a forthcoming solo album and ran off to produce Disco-Tex and his Sex-o-lettes.)
Chapter image 2

The “Bob’s” in the studio …...Who's the Producer here? …...It's all in the body language!! Photo of Crewe and Gaudio at Mirasound Studio NYC - courtesy of George Schowerer 1967 (Sound Engineer)

I don't mean to discredit anybody,” says Valli, “but Bob Gaudio in my opinion had produced everything in those early Four Seasons records. He also sat and worked out every arrangement on everything the Four Seasons or Frankie Valli ever did – including 'Can't Take My Eyes Off You' – and never was credited”.

Why is that?….asked the interviewer

“Because he was not the assigned producer and he was an intricate part of the Four Seasons. Bob Crewe was the official producer and he wasn't about to split his production credits with anybody. Bob Gaudio has had ten or twelve years of classical music under his belt; besides the fact that he also writes lyrics. Bob Gaudio is, was and always will be a melody chord writer, a true music writer.” “Bob Crewe is a music writer in this sense: without anybody to play chords and melodies, how are you gonna write music? Bob Crewe has not had any writing success unless it's been with somebody else – which tells you something immediately”.

Bob Crewe, taking an opposite view, has something to tell Frankie Valli.

“I don't know what kind of credit he (Gaudio) wanted,” he says evenly. “I think Bob got his credit as a writer. If you're gonna start that, you have to start giving more credit to the assigned arranger, who was usually Charlie Calello. There are no bad memories in my head. If somebody feels something was done improperly, I don't. If you want to go around throwing bitter pills saying 'Hey I put that music together, I should have been called the producer', well that problem is your own to digest. That was one of the reasons why we split”.
Chapter image 3

Bob Crewe producing Frankie Valli on ‘Can’t Take My Eyes Off You’ Mirasound Studio 1967 …..Bob Gaudio and the orchestra are in the background – Photo courtesy of George Schowerer (Sound Engineer)

The reality is that Bob Crewe taught the Four Seasons not only how to perform a hit record but how to produce it. Without Crewe's brilliance it is clear, looking back at their hits and Crewe's career that, they may never have succeeded as they did.

In so many ways they owe him their success. 'Jersey Boys' almost portrays this!! Fortunately Bob recovered from his 'hit and run' accident and would again be collaborating with them before the end of our story. Bob Gaudio believed through the late 60s and early 70s that he could produce as well as, if not better than, Crewe and he could hold up the 'Who Loves You' album as a prime example. But Crewe did rightly cite all the early Vee-Jay hits and the Philips productions which owed so much to him and Charlie Calello. And it was the Bob Crewe produced tracks on 'Close-Up' that gave Valli two major hits and the album its strength, clearly a strong argument to support Crewe's statement. Bob Gaudio admits to the clash of egos in interview in the fall of 1972 as revealed in Chapter 4, and despite their restriction to working together as 'writers' they still found producing together impossible. At Motown they were listed as co-writers, which they had done since 1962 and as Producer[Crewe] and Vocal Arranger[Gaudio] on some Tape Box Credits.

Whatever the arguments, by 1977 Bob Gaudio was about to be tested once again as a producer in his own right rather than a writer working with a 'non-musician' producer. Bob Gaudio took the Four Seasons into the studio for their new album, without any Crewe involvement, as he had done with 'Who Loves You', the previous 'platinum' album. As the papers reported….in December 1976:

” The Four Seasons spent over 6 weeks in the Sound Factory studio LA recording their new 'Helicon' album for Warner Bros. Out in the USA in Jan and the UK Feb the pencilled single is 'If We Should Lose Our Love' “

All in preparation for a 1977 World Tour - a ‘parting of the ways’ tour it appeared!

For many fans of the Four Seasons, the mid-70s tours were our first chance to see a legendary group but with a new format. In the UK they left us completely knocked out by their quality, and their great shows were something many concert attendees had never experienced before. Many of us didn't know the old line-ups or of the showmanship of Joe Long. (although some had been lucky to experience this back in 1971 and 72 and the famous UK 'cabaret' tours following the success of 'You're Ready Now' in the UK charts - Nr 11 in Nov 1970) But what we did acknowledge in 1976 and 77 was the quality of the musicianship and the vocals within this Four Seasons. And with Frankie's exceptional voice they had a musical and vocal range no others had at that time.

Ray Nichol captured the essence of what this group achieved on their UK tours.

“The thing about the group that I recall from the several performances and post concert meetings I attended was that they were a 'Band for the People'. They really were comfortable together as a group and always friendly to their public”
Chapter image 4

Don Ciccone celebrates the award of a gold disc. Photo courtesy of John Paiva

“And as performers they were also (musically) very tight. I think that Lee Shapiro was a key force in achieving this…..and John Paiva was such a comfortable lead guitarist. Nothing appeared to be an effort for him to play and he just carried so much confidence in his playing. The group was so good and had so much potential that perhaps Frankie Valli feared they may have become more popular than him on their own?”

A key point perhaps with the group planning for their solo career, as Valli was planning his own.

March 3 1977 Los Angeles Times featured an article that stated that “this is the last time Frankie Valli will be touring with the Four Seasons and he will move into a solo career in September.” He was quoted as wanting to focus on 'meaty ballads' “The Four Seasons will continue their touring routine.”...he said The respective US/UK fan clubs issued statements that this was “not a bad move”

Chapter image 5

'Easily', a 'Bubbling Under' Billboard hit at #108

and had been on the cards for some time and they each committed to supporting both performing entities. A degree of re-assurance to fans was clearly needed

Private Stock where busy promoting David Soul who hit #1 on April 16th with 'Don't Give Up On Us Baby' (a Jan 15th No 1 in the UK) on the back of his success in the TV series 'Starsky and Hutch'…….Valli's lack of solo success in terms of follow on singles showed that he wasn't getting the promotion he had previously enjoyed in 1976.

'Easily/What Good Am I Without You' PVT-98/US PS 45-140 was released in March/April in the US/UK respectively and poorly reviewed as “not suitable for the disco market.” Steve Bailey of the US fan club said it was hard to get a copy even in LA, New York and Philadelphia, but it almost made the Billboard Top 100 in April. There were stories of fans taking copies to New York radio stations and being turned away as the material was rated 'unsuitable'. Apparently it was selected from the 'Valli' album after “intensive market research”. 'Can't Get You Off My Mind' came a close second. An interesting result as Valli had achieved 3 hits previously, two in the disco market and one a ballad: and the ballad had needed six months promotion to reach # 1. So in the market research surprisingly the disco track lost out. Maybe no-one considered a double 'A' side release to address both markets. In the USA a 12” (33-1/3rd )featuring

Chapter image 6

Photos of the group members appeared on the back of the 'Helicon' album to try to enable the public to identify with them

the disco track 'Boomerang' and 'Swearin' To God' with 'Can't Get You Off My Mind' was issued. The problem really was that Private Stock were not promoting Valli's releases (Irving Beegle the Vice president who had pushed for the ‘Valli’ album resigned)

Back with Warner-Curb and the 'Helicon' album - Warner-Curb BS 3016 was released in UK on 5th March and in the USA on 15th April. A new direction for the group, it was predominantly the Four Seasons with Frankie Valli 'guesting' as part lead vocalist on 4 of the tracks.

A Record Mirror review gave it a 3 star rating and said : “the good voices of the Four Seasons meant the group should have no problem establishing themselves when Valli leaves the group in September”.

The US fan club said that:

“while 'Who Loves You' was a step away from what we were all used to hearing. HELICON is a mile. It is tremendous…..the music is heavy, not 'bubble gum'. The airplay will be primarily FM. The Four Seasons have totally turned around. The sound is young and vibrant, the music is complex, and the lyrics are simple. The tracks include heavy use of Moog and synthesizers. The arrangements are impeccable….a very conscious effort to stamp the album with a definitive Four Seasons style, much different from the 'original' Four Seasons style. It's a new group and theirs is new music”

Initially, many UK fans were worried that the sound had moved too far away from the style of the 'Who Loves You' album having more of a rock flavour and less melody and harmony. But everyone supported the group and attended the concerts and bought the album. Although billed as a final tour by Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons the fans were committed to both. Lavish promo went into the tour and the photo sessions featured a very distinctive set of sweaters that everyone envied and wanted. John Paiva recalls: “The story behind the photo of the group in the 'star-fish' sweaters for the 1977 tour programme (and the K-Tel album) is interesting.

Chapter image 7
A company was selected to hand make these and had a team of people making them right up to the photo-shoot. When they arrived we were amazed by the individual designs for each of us. The material and craftsmanship was unbelievable. We wore them for the 'shoot', took them off and they were whisked away and we never saw them again”

On April 13th Roxy Theatre LA, the Four Seasons gave a concert WITHOUT Frankie Valli. Billboard gave it a poor review. Ed Harrison said of the concert:

”While on vinyl the band still sounds invigorating, on stage the SEASONS lack the charismatic appeal that packed audiences for 15 years. Instead it is reduced in stature to an ordinary 'rock band' playing some catchy tunes that become less stimulating as the evening wears on”, and he continues, ”..the show sagged as Valli relinquished the stage to show off the band.” Although the reviewer recognized that the 'Helicon' material might generate a hit he found the delivery 'lack-lustre' “

The fans didn't agree particularly during the UK tour which immediately followed.

The Tour dates

London Palladium - 26 April - 30th April (total 8 shows).Guests - The Nolan Sisters. Liverpool Empire - 5 May (2 shows). Sheffield City Hall - 6 May (2 shows). Manchester Apollo - 7 May (2 shows). Wolverhampton Civic Hall - 8 May (2 shows).

May 9th to 19th Europe dates (no known performances but for TV miming and radio interviews).

EUROPE - May 20th to June 9th

THE WORLD - Australia and New Zealand: May 20th Perth; May 23rd, 24th Adelaide; May 25th, 26th Melbourne; May 28th, 29th Sydney; June 1st Brisbane; June 3rd, 4th Auckland, New Zealand.

May 5th saw 'Rhapsody/Helicon' UK Warner Bros K16932 released as the tour gathered momentum. It entered the UK Top 50 on 31st May at 59 climbing to a final position of #37 on 21st. It was Tony Blackburn's ‘record of the week’.

The UK tour didn't open well as John Paiva recalls happenings at the London Palladium on opening night.

“We had rehearsed during the day with the London Philharmonic strings and they were great. The one thing we didn't do was to open the curtain at the rehearsal. We suggested to Jim that we should run through the opening as the mike stands would have to be moved forward after the curtain rises. As Frankie wanted to leave Jim said we shouldn't bother. Our opening number was 'Swearing To God' which started with the guitar in full distortion starting the melody line, and then holding the note to Gerry's drum roll. A very effective opening. Over that came the announcement: “Ladies and gentlemen, the London Palladium proudly presents…. Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons! lights ….camera ….action …..CURTAIN. In this wonderful old theatre the heavy curtain has a steel chain sewn into the bottom to keep it steady and hanging straight down as with most theatre curtains. When the curtain was speedily opened, it swung backwards catching Don's mike, which fell into my mike, which landed directly across the tuning pegs of my Gibson knocking it completely out of tune. The mike stand finished its trip by landing directly on my pedal board activating all of my sound settings….chorus…the 2nd distortion….the flanger….the delay…and the envelope follower. All this accompanying Frankie's singing. Nice eh!?! I couldn't help but laugh at the absurdity of it all. My backup guitar was on its stand so I missed a few beats but after a few seconds I was there, where I should be. Yeeeaa…….. Professional show business.”
Chapter image 8

Manchester Apollo - 7 May . Photo courtesy of Brian Lomas

Chapter image 9
Chapter image 10

On Stage 1977. Courtesy of John Paiva

Although the external image was of a together group, it was a PR image as John told us….

“In England we partied with Elton John and The Eagles at a shindig thrown by Warner Bros. for The Eagles most recent album. We were told to be at the party. When we showed, Frankie was sitting with some people. Naturally we started over to his table but were cut off by Jim.(the road manager) Frankie wanted us to sit elsewhere.”

They all accepted their place…as ‘employees’

The World Tour proved hugely successful and the group was interviewed several times as the press and fans sought re-assurance re the future. Some of the interviews were quite revealing……..and an ad-hoc road stop enabled Frankie Valli to get some sun on his legs!!!!!

Chapter image 11

John: Hey Frankie...What's this I read about your clothes fetish.

Frankie: No John I dig shoes! Photo courtesy of John Paiva

Whilst in New Zealand Frankie revealed his fetish for clothes in an interview in Auckland: ”I'm a clothes freak really. I can't resist buying clothes and my wardrobe at home is sure pretty big.”

Frankie's clothes addiction was also confirmed by John Paiva:

”When in London Frankie heard about a quality boot-maker in the city and we paid a visit. Frankie asked what colours they were available in….”Four or five….brown, red, white etc…” said the boot-maker…”OK” said Frankie. I'll have them all…send them to me. Some months later we were rehearsing at Frankie's home and he gave me a tour and showed me his 'dressing-room'. One wall was covered in shoes and there amongst them were five pairs of boots from England. They must have cost $800 a pair. I don't know if he ever wore them ……but he said he just liked them….an example of the trappings of success, I suppose.”
Chapter image 12

In an interview on Capitol Radio (London) during the 1977 tour Valli and the group talked about the future

Roger Scott interviewed Frankie Valli and Gerry Polci in what should have been a half hour interview but turned into about an hour and a half. "Red Hot Roger Scott" knew his stuff and Frankie just wasn't prepared for what hit him, Roger started the interview by asking about The 4 Lovers and the pre Seasons stuff before playing 'My Mothers Eyes' to which Frankie shouts "Take it off" Roger replies "NO!" and Frankie actually tried to lift the arm off the deck of the turntable. Roger then played 'Bermuda' and it went on from there. There was some discussion about the troubles at Motown and after that he talked about Frankie leaving the group saying that the public wouldn't accept it. Frankie said “oh they will”. This is an extract:- Frankie:

”I think there really is more emphasis on the fact that the Four Seasons will be going on without me, and what is going to happen then is really necessary. You know, we could've done this a whole other way. We could've taken the same four guys, created a new name and you know a lot of …..”

But Frankie was interrupted by the DJ….”it wouldn't be The Four Seasons!!” Frankie replies…

“That's very true because it can outgrow you. There's definitely evolution. The toughest hurdle to get over was that we used the name the Four Seasons. I mean, that already was tough. To establish a situation or establish a success with anybody singing lead in the Four Seasons, I mean, it's already a difficult thing”… He was asked…”Surely the toughest hurdle is gonna be the first concert where it's the Four Seasons and they all come on and they think that you're gonna walk out there?”

Frankie:

“The one point that I'd like to hit on is the fact that we originally planned to develop more than one lead singer for a couple of reasons.
Chapter image 13
Chapter image 14
First of all, in the original Four Seasons there was only one lead singer, that was the reason I did all the leads. I would've very happily welcomed someone else to sing some leads, especially nights when we were doing performances and I was feeling a little under the weather or whatever. Gerry just had a great sound right from the beginning, developing what he's doing now, you know, so that he could sing contemporary music and get a better feel for it. He made it easy you know. He already had the facility and that's the major part of it”

“ Lotta help though, lotta help”!...added Gerry

Chapter image 15

Frankie:

“It probably will be the last English tour together. The group and I will be working together right up until September; we will still be very close, in contact with each other. We'll still care about each other and have a feeling and a love for each other. It's just that I feel I should in no way stand in the way of the development of the other people. They're talented enough to happen on their own and I think it would be a hindrance more than a help for me to be there. I don't think it's fair because some people would stand and compare our successes or careers. And they probably can go on to have as long a success as the original Four Seasons had. But the hardest thing is – we've gotten over the roughest hurdle. We've been able to develop success with the Four Seasons without Frankie Valli. “Silver Star” was without Frankie Valli at all. “December '63”, Frankie Valli sang two lines.”

Roger; “But a lot of people don't realise that, they automatically think FOUR SEASONS – FRANKIE VALLI.

Chapter image 16

Frankie: I think they do. I think they're really tuned and they're much more aware than we sometimes give them credit for.

Valli was struggling to explain the plan and clearly the split was not fully developed.

Chapter image 17
“If they know in advance that I'm not gonna walk out there, and it's advertised right and there's no misconception, I think they will really be very pleased with what they hear and what they see. Now, I'm very close to the situation, probably closer than anybody and I have more feeling for it than anybody. And I'm more honest about it than most anybody else would be because it's something that I'm a part of. I've watched it grow; it's like sending your children out into the world. It's the same thing.”

The group were certainly not that: after all, the lawyer for the Four Seasons Partnership had made it very clear in a Crawdaddy magazine article in February 1977 what the true relationship was:-

“Peter Bennett Esq., the Four Seasons' attorney since 1969, fills in the blanks: “Bob Gaudio and Frankie own the name, “The Four Seasons,” and the present members of the group are under exclusive contract to them for all personal appearances, TV, recording, everything. They are employees of The Four Seasons Partnership and do not perform without Frankie Valli. If the personnel of The Four Seasons needs to be changed for any reason it can be done at any time by terminating the contracts of the employees.” “Also, Gaudio and Valli own the masters of all the Four Seasons' records from their biggest period with Vee-Jay and Mercury/Phillips. They are leased periodically to companies like Private Stock or the Longines Symphonette Society. This is handled very carefully. Not long ago, the entire old Four Seasons product was withdrawn from the market for a period of two years as a merchandising move; we calculated that the absence of the old records would create a new demand and we were quite correct. Perhaps we'll do that again in the future.” “When Frankie Valli signed a contract with Private Stock, and the Four Seasons signed with Warner Brothers/Mike Curb, we decided to give up the rights to future masters so that we could have two separate recording entities. Valli and Gaudio do not retain ownership of these new records but both companies can release only the product we designate and only when we designate it. This gives us complete control over which record follows which and that prevents Frankie Valli's records from conflicting with Four Seasons records, especially those on which Frankie appears. One label couldn't handle it as well. Frankly, I don't know of any other group with an analogous contractual situation”.

Just to add to the confusion the published music to ‘Down The Hall’ featured the NEW Four Seasons, whilst the pic sleeve to the 45 showed Valli as part of the group when he doesn’t appear on the track

Chapter image 18
Chapter image 19

The article continues:

”In other words, Valli and Gaudio at last have the independent record deal they've always wanted. The Four Seasons you used to know and love no longer exists. Even Warner Bros realises you wouldn't recognize the group anymore so it is putting a photo of the present “employees” on the jacket of their “debut” LP.(i.e. 'Helicon') But the smart money in the industry says you'll strike up a long-term romance with these ringers, just as you embraced a reconstituted King Kong and a diet Dr Pepper. They're probably right, since “December 1963” was the best selling single in the groups, err, name, err, Four Seasons existence

That was the feed to the public but John Paiva recalls the reality of their contract arrangements…

“We, as a group and individually, stupidly signed a producers contract where we were not signed to the record company (Warner Bros.), but to Frankie Valli and Bob Gaudio....The Producers. None of us was about to get rich being in this group. Frankie Valli and Bob Gaudio came up through the ranks and earned their money through lots of hard work and were not about to part with any of it too easily. I still believe that I was really the only one who was foolish enough to be a company man. I believed in the Four Seasons Partnership and felt that I was safe in the fold. There was a hard and bitter lesson ahead. The studio time money on the “Who Loves You” project was great, but I received no ‘points’ on the album. Later when we were to do the Helicon album, I was a full fledged member of The Four Seasons. This project featured more of the four of us than Frankie. It came out great. When we went into Bob Gaudio's office to discuss the deal it was individually. Warner Brothers was giving the producers (Frankie and Bob) 9 %. The deal went down like this: 1.The producers got 6 % : 2.The Four Seasons got 3 % : 3.Don and Gerry (lead singers) each would get 1 % : 4. Lee (the pianist arranger) got ½ of 1 % : 5. I singer/guitarist would get ½ of 1 %. All Bob told me was of my ½ of 1 %. This sounded less than satisfactory to me and I told Bob so. His reaction was of disinterest. I pressed on a bit further by asking “What are my options?” Answer: “You could NOT do the album.” It was clear that I was apparently of little importance.
Chapter image 20
The fact that we all had been putting our hearts into our work and truly loved performing and doing our best meant nothing to them. I was not living under the false impression that I was unique and could not be replaced. I simply believed that I was a member and had some say. Wrong again. The relationship never improved and there was no love lost when the breakup came.”

This was the reality of the music business…it is a business designed to make money. But sometimes it was financially beneficial when TV performances were done:-

“Back home we did the Mike Douglas Show quite often mouthing our recordings and being interviewed. So often that it got to be routine. The money was always good. The original showing and the first repeat would be full pay. The second repeat ½, the third less. But then the appearance would be used so often that there was always a little more throughout the year. These little extras were good as our base pay was not so hot.”
Chapter image 21

Three Four Seasons plus backing singers. Left to Right, Kim O'Kelley-Leigh, Lee Shapiro, John Paiva, Hali Burton, Gerry Polci, Sandra Chriss

This was typical of the types of contract that existed in the industry and was derived from the Warner Bros deal Bob Gaudio had struck. John's comments reveal a naivety that many recording artists have experienced. From the 1960s through to the 1990's artists received a miniscule percentage of sales income. Record companies argued that they carried all of the risk, and the production and promotion costs but research of any industry analysis of the period shows the huge profits and salaries earned by Record Companies and their executives. It was just the accepted way. No artist could promote themselves as they can today(2010). Only today are the public aware of the greed and corruption that prevailed within the record business. Books like 'Dirty Little Secrets of the Record Business' by Hank Bordowitz shows how the business “deteriorated from one that showcased the performer's creativity and individuality”…….and “fouled its own livelihood-through shortsightedness, stubbornness, power plays, sloth and outright greed”

So what was really going on with the group - and did anyone care about the fans? A Goldmine article again tried to portray to the fans the plans for the group to be independent:-

“In truth, since Valli co-owned with Gaudio the Four Seasons name, he wouldn't really be severing his ties with the group. However, the Four Seasons without Valli on record or stage would be an entirely different entity. From April until October Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons packed houses across the United States and Great Britain with Valli's “farewell” tour. Valli explained to reporters that he could no longer bear the rigors of the road and by splitting off he could concentrate on his solo career. Further, he did not want to “stand in the way” of the momentum created by the new Four Seasons band. The public got a preview of the new sound with the release of the “Helicon” album. 90% of the lead vocals were done by Polci or Ciccone. The ninth and last track, added in April, was “Down The Hall”. Valli didn't even participate in its recording. Polci sang lead on this song, with background vocals limited to Ciccone. The album was progressive rock but possessed enough harmony to carry the Four Seasons trademark. Each of the six members was individually pictured on the back cover and identified!

The group were happy with what they had done on 'Helicon'. John Paiva totally believed in it and in their performances. It was however Bob Gaudio's 'concept' and they used their talent to deliver it very competently. Lee Shapiro is somewhat more philosophical about it:-

“….. although we were all glad to be creating more adventurous and intricate music, the lyric content wasn't Bob's best (in my opinion). That said, if Helicon had been a big hit, we would have all been "trail blazers". In hindsight, we all commented that we would have liked to have followed up the style of "Dec. 63". But, we bore no risk, creatively or financially. Who wouldn't have followed Bob's lead? Quite simply the 70s "4 Seasons" were an outlet for Bob Gaudio's writing and production talents and we were all too happy to be a part of it. We were actually quite enthusiastic about all the new stuff Gaudio wrote but, in the end result, it just didn't sound like we had made a hit. I believe making a hit was secondary to Bob at that point. He was more concerned with making a creative statement which can be a risky venture. If it works, you're a genius. If not, you hold the bag.”

Once again words that echo the Chameleon album quotes from Bob Gaudio himself back in 1972. Although it was 1978 he once again just wrote from his creative perspective at that time and didn't look for a hit in what he wrote.

Chapter image 22

'1977 on tour — Photo courtesy of John Paiva'

And at the time the promo for the split was being pushed by them all as Gerry Polci said on Capitol Radio London when asked:

“Have you thought about that day when you go out alone? “What's happening now is that we're promoting our latest album which is the “Helicon” album and we've got some very, very good reaction from it. And so, being afraid to go out, as long as the people realise what they're getting. If they know that Frankie's not gonna be there, and if they know that we're gonna do material that we do by ourselves, there's less of a chance of getting any repercussions from Frankie not being there. We're all very excited about it. The situation has come about over the past four years. I've been a Four Season for the last four years, doing Four Seasons material, watching the thing grow and evolve into a, as Frankie says, a situation where other people are singing leads and the instrumentalists are much more featured. In the “Helicon” album it's much more prevalent than any other thing that has been recorded by the Four Seasons…. we believe in what we're doing and we believe in the material and like I said a lot of help from Bobby and Frank that has helped us along a great deal.”

Goldmine again looked back on the album release in the 1980s.’Helicon’ sold very poorly. Fans felt that Warner-Curb missed a sure bet by not releasing “Rhapsody” as its single release, instead going with “Down The Hall”. The latter made most charts but never broke big.

Chapter image 23

Rhapsody / Helicon /Four Seasons - (Warner Bros 45)

The group gave their 'take' independently of Frankie Valli when they were interviewed in Holland for an article which appeared in the Winschuter Courant on 21st May 1977 entitled 'The Four Seasons – A Hard Working Group'

“Gerry please tell us…Are you content about “Helicon?” ……….“No, not at all. You never are, I think, because you are obliged to make some compromises. But we are most content about the direction we've got into. It all started with the “Who Loves You” album. Helicon is the next step. The record is a mixture of moods. More rock than ever. Now we have to wait to see what this record is doing. If it's not successful, then we will try and put out music in a different way. We make and play everything by ourselves. We believe in our music and that is the reason we will be successful. At least, that's how I think about it……. “We are working very hard to show we are the group who is appearing on stage is the group on the record, if you know what I mean”. What is Frankie's part on the Helicon album? …...Gerry: “He sings perhaps 10% from the songs and you can hear him on the background. I sing, let's say 53% of the songs on the Helicon LP. Now that Frankie wants to go his own way, we use the abilities we have in the group. Frankie Valli and the 4 Seasons was a bit too much for one stage, what's why we split. Frankie as well as the 4 Seasons deserve their own career's”. Gerry, being 25, is not the youngest Season. Lee is. “You can see that” Gerry says. “With these guys we have been playing for four years now. We are part of the evolution, that's why we hold the name the 4 Seasons”. When I was asked to join the group I knew the group very well, of course. In the United States the 4 Seasons are as popular as the Beatles. To me, it was a unique chance to reveal myself to this music”.

The 4 Seasons needed some time to develop themselves. Gerry Polci is content now and says the group is more instrumental than they ever were.

“The Band is playing better than they ever did. It's very nice to see that our Helicon LP is tip of the week on your Dutch radio station. After Holland we are visiting Germany, Paris, Australia and New Zealand and after that the hospital I'm afraid. It is a very tiring life, but we enjoy it and that is very important. In June we are going back to the States to work for our new album. To make a record and to appear for our public are two worlds apart. I like to be in a studio. During a record session you have to strive after absolute perfection. To appear is for the excitement”

The group appeared in a solo format several times during the summer.

The question was one Gerry and the group were aware of….but not actually saying out loud…… “Would the American audience accept us in our new style.” His thoughts were….”

“They knew the group since 1962 with Frankie as lead singer. All at once, they saw a totally new group. We gave promotion concerts in five big towns, like New York, and Chicago. Frankie only was there to open the shows and to introduce us. I think it was quite a success. “December 1963” sold very well in the States. 2.8 million copies, not bad is it not? In this way we proved the 4 Seasons can sing in another way. If the audience accept us, then it's okay, if not then we are movin' to Holland!” -

Which the Beach Boys had done in 1973 with new members in the group!!

But we fans wondered - would the mass audience accept them? Perhaps in Europe (with enough promotion), but the Partnership still saw their primary market as the USA and things were not looking good there at all. The instability in the Record Business was going to make the next few years a roller-coaster.

Warner Bros Promo-Photo for the NEW Four Seasons in preparation for their launch

Chapter image 24

ChapterReferences/Credits

Goldmine Article – The Four Seasons - A Lesson in Survival by Rex Woodard 1981: Article From A Warner Bros Circular November 1984 by Joshua Baer Titled “4 Seasons To Consider”; “Out Of Season” by John Paiva (unpublished biography); Four Seasons UK Appreciation Society Newsletters: Brian Gari for The Entertainment Spectrum Dec 1976: Special thanks for contributions to: Charles Calello: Lee Shapiro: Frank Rovello: Ken Charmer: George Ingram: Lynn Boleyn: Ray Nichol: Malcolm Grace: Brian Lomas